Nobre sticking to his guns. Are we?

It’s in our nature to nourish dreams. Nothing wrong with that, on the contrary. But when dreams are not fulfilled, we mustn’t react like we’ve been deprived of what’s rightfully ours.

Back in January, few actually believed Palmeiras would make it to the knockout phase in the Libertadores Cup. There were even question marks in regard to progressing in the Paulista. Suddenly, the squad reacted with a streak of victories and those dreams, oh those dreams…

But Palmeiras were eliminated from the São Paulo Cup, then from the Libertadores Cup. Obviously not on any palmeirense’s script, but… Surprising? Not really. Disappointing? Certainly. A reason for heavily criticising the Nobre management? Absolutely not.

What Nobre’s doing should be recognised: he’s following a plan. It’s a bit worrying actually having to point this out, but in the heat of the moment far too many supporters seem to have forgotten what’s been repeatedly damaging not only Palmeiras but most football clubs in Brazil since forever:  a lacking mid to long-term strategy, paired with professionalism. Nobre was elected to bring exactly that. But now, many criticise him for keeping his promise, not giving in to quick fixes aimed at boosting Palmeiras’ chances in this year’s first two competitions.

Palmeiras’ financial situation is bad, very bad. “Spend yourself out of the crisis, buy top players, win trophies: revenues and bonuses will come!”. Right. That’s the mentality we’re supposed to fight, remember?

Nobre’s plan is based on careful diagnostics of Palmeiras’ situation and follows a logical progression. Some people with access say that implementation is running its course more or less as expected. The goal this year is one and one only: give the club best possible conditions to assemble a squad that will bring Palmeiras back to the first division in 2014. Nothing else matters.

Decades of amateurish management are not reverted in three month’s time. A whole mindset of do’s and don’ts are not easily reverted either. Some of the heaviest criticism of the actual administration seem to be coming from some of those most desperately desiring change. Is that desire fogging their reasoning? Are they really thinking that we’d see profound changes to Palmeiras on and off the pitch after three months of new management? I don’t know. But I do know that the current polarisation of opinions at large seems both unnecessary and counterproductive. In late 2012, when the direct vote was the hot subject, there was unity. Some of that, if not a lot, seems lost.

Freedom of speech is fundamental. Now, with speech comes responsibilities. We are all – in one way or the other, and certainly on different magnitudes – opinion-makers. Is my opinion well-founded? Am I working in benefit of Palmeiras by voicing it? What do I want to achieve? These questions and others should be reflected upon before pressing that “send” or “publish” button. As of late, I see a lot of gasoline being poured over perfectly manageable fires.

There are no guarantees Nobre and his directors will succeed. Time will tell. Remember, the primary goal is ascent. That’s the yardstick. Give the man some time, give the man some room to manoeuvre. And please, give him the benefit of the doubt. After all, he was elected on those premises.

Scoppia che la vittoria è nostra!


  1. Ah, o encanto do imediatismo… Por que não me surpreendo com esta mentalidade do “50 anos em 5” enraizada no sonho naïve do brasileiro desde a era JK? Mas então, a estrada é feita de escolhas. E a cada escolha, muitas renúncias. E cada uma com sua complexidade, impactos e tempo de maturação. A realidade permanece implacável não importa o quanto nossa “ingenuidade coletiva” possa perceber em contrário… Avanti, Palmeiras!

  2. Muito bom, Kristian, concordo plenamente! O Palmeiras não vai se recuperar e melhorar do dia pra noite: no início do ano o próprio Nobre pediu paciência e colaboração com a torcida de que a situação é péssima e a solução é a longo prazo.

    Resta a nós esperar e ver! Eu confio na diretoria!

  3. Well written! Both in content and English. I’m new in this site, and to be honest I don’t even know the reason your article is written in English isntead of Portuguese. If you don’t mind please give me some of your background. Thanks!

  4. De fato, o Palmeiras está com dividas e se encontra em uma situação financeira delicada, sei que nesse ano o objetivo é voltar para a primeira divisão, mas não esqueçamos, 2014 é o centenário do Palmeiras, no ano mais importante de nossa história merecemos um time a altura da mesma, só nos resta confiar no trabalho do Paulo Nobre.

  5. there’s no secret: let the folks do their work and keep supporting. although we’re eager to see a new way of doing such things, we must be reasonable to acknowledge that huge structural changes take a lot of time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s